Hammers1993
4:18 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
I don't get all this bollocks that if a ref see's it the outcome can't be changed.
Why?
If you make a mistake in work, it would get rectified. You wouldn't just go, oh yeah he saw that it was a mistake so that is that, can't be changed now.
If a ref get's a decision wrong, which he did do, he didn't even give Barnes a yellow for that tackle, it should be reviewed and rectified, i.e 3 game ban.
Matic was within his rights to push him to the ground, that still is a red mind.
|
Trevor B
4:17 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
that rule is shite and needs to be rewrote
|
LeroysBoots
4:16 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
Bizarre
@FA: In line with this rationale, FA confirm no further action in relation to Ashley Barnes as incident was seen by the officials 5/5
|
SnarestoneIron
4:05 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
Eddie B 2:31 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
I don't see how you can say he saw it for what it really was...or he would have been sent off at the time! There's no grey area here, it was a straight red, end of story.
|
Grumpster
3:13 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
Hammer29 2:42 Mon Feb 23
That's quality
|
Super Scotty
3:10 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
I wouldn't normally think they'd win the appeal but after this weekend's matches it wouldn't surprise me. If I were them I'd definitely compare it to Vertoghen's incredibly similar push on Noble which didn't even get a yellow.
Part of me wants him to win the appeal too, without Matic I can see Chelsea losing to Spurs in the Capital One final. No one wants that!
|
Hermit Road
3:00 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
Got no problem with what Matic did. You should be allowed to do that if someone nearly breaks your leg. I thought he was restrained to be honest,it's not as if he netted the bloke.
|
Sven Roeder
2:51 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
Joey Barton pushed some Hull player and that was ignored until he hit Huddlestone in the bollocks.
When does a push go from nothing to yellow to red?
I would rank offences in terms of the harm they cause or were intended to cause (ie swinging a punch or a two footed tackle that is avoided) and most handbag offences should see players told to get on with the game.
|
ornchurch ammer
2:50 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
If he wasn't held back by Terry and Zouma then he would have done a lot more than push him.
He had to go, frivolous appeal, two game ban. Simples
|
penners28
2:47 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
he had no chance of staying on his feet though did he?
|
Rossal
2:45 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
He did only push him......if Barnes doesnt go down and stays on his feet probs just a yellow
|
penners28
2:45 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
if that appeal is upheld it opens all kinds of cans of worms. i hope they get an extra match ban for doing so. that means that people can retaliate how they want when they are fouled.
|
Sven Roeder
2:44 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
There was some odd refereeing at the weekend and unfortunately I think Mourinho was right in his outrage about minute 30 minute whatever.
To be honest Noble should have got the second yellow (though the first was soft bollocks) and Vertonghen should have got a straight red for pushing him as he did. Was worse than Matic's
|
Boris the Beard
2:42 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
Cant beleive anyone thinks it should be recinded, tackle was horrendous but he reaction is a red all day long. He misses our game so fucking good
|
Hammer29
2:42 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
I love this. This also happened at the weekend. Another bad tackle but the reaction is slightly more than a shove!
http://www.bbc.co.uk/sport/0/football/31572147
|
Private Dancer
2:37 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
If the player had been standing next to him and he pushed him he probably would have got a yellow, but the fact that he run 10 yards and pushed him in the back, it just didn't look good. Doubt he'll get off.
|
Sven Roeder
2:35 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
Think it sums up modern football that Barnes will get nothing for this incident and Matic will miss 3 games including a cup final.
This rule about incompetent refs being protected needs to go.
The tackle deserves a ban
|
Steve P
2:32 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
I don't think Matic will get off either. It will be interesting to see if he gets another match ban for a frivolous appeal!
|
stewie griffin
2:32 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
tbf, I think its mad that's considered a red card offence. A little shove, yellow at most.
Proper gay, is modern football
|
Eddie B
2:31 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
Barnes won't get anything as the ref saw it.
Matic won't get off as it was clearly retaliaiton.
|
Steve P
2:29 Mon Feb 23
Re: Chelsea to appeal Matic's red card
|
Well, exactly - if he gets off, he can play.
|
| 
